Would You Look At The Way This Gen X Reddit MOD Talked To Me?

So you know my last post, about latchkey kids? I made the mistake of posting it to the Gen X subreddit, with a link back to the blog, without getting permission to do so. 

I shouldn't have done that, but apparently this is an offense so egregious as to permanently ban me from the subreddit! I was stunned. I replied to the MOD, and they get to hide behind anonymity mind you, that I didn't realize I was in violation of the rules? I tried to explain. They absolutely tore my head off. They claimed I had had "several" posts removed, and had "MULTITUDES" of messages and have ignored everything...ummmm...dude, what?

It's true that I had a couple of posts removed, that I was baffled as to why they would be removed. One was about whether Gen X was the last generation to go to work on Halloween in costume. In its entirety, this was the removed post:

Halloween costumes at work?

Tag: Nostalgia

In the 90s I worked for a tech company, and only the weirdos dressed up for Halloween. Me among them. Another woman on the other coast would dress up too. We would grab conference rooms, fire up the video conference software, just to show each other our costumes. So fun. Does anyone dress up for Halloween at work anymore?

I never got any explanation for WHY it was removed, and I didn't complain. My post had 23 replies--a good conversation going--before the MOD took it down. No explanation. Okay, whatever.

Another post that was taken down I did have explained to me, not by the MOD who took it down, but by the other users--no Facebook links! I had posted a very Gen X image, and I thought the image itself would post, but instead a LINK to it on Facebook posted. You see, Reddit hates Facebook like the Red Sox fans hate the Yankees. It isn't a rule of the subreddit or anything. The users good-naturedly ribbed me about that Facebook gaffe, and I laughingly apologized profusely to everyone. The MOD took the post down, again without any explanation. They could have just told me not to use a Facebook link next time, to just post the image. That's what I would have done if I were a MOD. The image: 

Sleestacks!
 

Those are the only two times I've had posts removed from the Community Gen X, one I happen to care about, obviously. Two posts removed, one I have no idea why, and one I didn't realize was a no-no, but which is not exactly against the rules. Two. In five years. The MOD saying that I've had "several" posts removed is making the word "several" do a lot of heavy lifting, wouldn't you say? 

Now this latest post, the link back to this blog? I read the rules twice and I didn't see the part about not promoting your blog. I just didn't see it. I had just linked that entry, Gen X: The Era Of Latchkey Kids, to the BloggersCommunity subreddit, which does allow linking to blogs. In fact, it's what it's for--maybe I got confused, I don't know. When you post, it invites you to cross-post in another subreddit. Maybe I thought that the Gen X crowd would particularly enjoy and find community with that blog entry. I can't remember. I tried explaining about the stroke and how there's a certain degree of memory loss and brain fog. They didn't give a wet slap.

And what "MULTITUDES of messages" are they referring to? I have never once heard from a MOD from any subreddit. My inbox reflects that fact. What are they talking about? I'll post the whole exchange in a minute, but first, this is what it says on Reddit's main site about VALUES:

We believe Reddit is the most human place on the internet. It’s powered by the creativity, passion, and generosity of the people who spend time here and make it their own. We respect redditors and work hard to give them a place where self-expression can thrive and communities can achieve amazing things together.

We also remember that there are real people on the other side of the screen who lead full and complex lives. And often, when someone is struggling or in need of support, they come to Reddit to find help and understanding they can’t find elsewhere. We take this role seriously and aim to make Reddit a place where people can continue to find communities that accept and appreciate them for who they are.  (Emphasis mine.)

Having said all that, this is the exchange with the Gen X MOD: 


Feb 15 
 r/GenX MOD

Hello, You have been permanently banned from participating in /r/GenX because your post violates this community's rules. You won't be able to post or comment, but you can still view and subscribe to it.

If you have a question regarding your ban, you can contact the moderator team by replying to this message.

Reminder from the Reddit Admin team: If you use another account to circumvent this community ban, that will be considered a violation of the Reddit Rules and may result in your account being banned from the platform as a whole.

But I wasn’t advertising or selling anything, just sharing a post a...
r/GenX MOD
You were promoting your blog.
…just sharing a post about Gen X. There’s even flair for the topic! I didn’t think of it as “promoting.”
I didn’t realize.
r/GenX MOD
Again, you were promoting your blog.
I’m a Gen X blogger, how can I be banned from Gen X Reddit? I’m on it every day. I have had a Reddit account for five years. Can I have a second chance? I won’t post my blog anymore. I didn’t realize.
r/GenX MOD
You’ve had several posts removed, so you have either failed to read the rules of the subreddit or you have read the rules and chosen (repeatedly) to ignore those rules. We’re happy to revisit bans, but only after the banned member has read the rules, and understands them.
I remember that. I was surprised when they were taken down, I read the rules and couldn’t find where I was against the rules? They were Gen X posts. One was about Halloween costumes at work and was Gen X the last to do this. Honestly I don’t see how that’s against the rules. Maybe I just don’t understand. I had a stroke two years ago and there’s a certain degree of memory loss and brain fog. I wish you would have said something before permanently banning me.
r/GenX MOD
So you just want to make the argument that mods are wrong. Got it.
That’s not what I said, why are you being so mean to me?
r/GenX MOD
I have offered you a way to have your ban reconsidered. You have ignored it.
What was that? I didn’t see it?
r/GenX MOD
I’m not your mother, and I’m not going to hold your hand through this. Try reading the MULTITUDE of messages I have sent you.
It just says I have to read the rules and understand them.
How do I prove that I understand them?
Today is the first time I have seen any messages?
r/GenX MOD
Read the rules. Message the mod team when you have done so, and tell us you understand the rules.
Okay. I will do that. Sorry. I didn’t intend to violate any rules. In five years I have never had a problem with violating rules. I try to follow them at all times. I thought “promoting” involved sales or advertising and the like. I will read the rules again. It won’t happen again.
 
Feb 17
 
r/GenX MOD
Question. What did you find about this email exchange that you felt you needed to report it to Reddit?
I didn’t report it to Reddit. I don’t know anyone who would report it to Reddit.
Why do you think I reported it to Reddit? I don’t even know how to do that.
However, if someone above you has access to your email, I would venture to guess that they are surprised at how mean you were to me in that exchange. You’re quite harsh, if you want to know the truth. I am a nice person and I made an honest mistake. Does Reddit have access to your email, is that the issue?
r/GenX MOD
🙄

You have been permanently muted from r/GenX. You will not be able to message the moderators of r/GenX.

"Permanently muted" means what it says. I wasn't able to talk to them anymore, nor could I talk to someone else. Why? This is flabbergasting, and moreover, I feel baited by that question " What did you find about this email exchange that you felt you needed to report it to Reddit?" I answered honestly--I didn't report it to Reddit. I probably should have. I didn't think of it. Because I'm not a mean, vindictive, angry person? Now I want to be a MOD. Someone should hold this person accountable for their unhinged behavior.

I feel that if this is the kind of person they have as a MODERATOR of a Reddit Community that I've been a contributor to for five years, in good standing, then they have a bigger problem than a post-stroke Gen X blogger mistakenly posting a Gen X post in their Gen X Community. They have a bully, that's what they have. Someone who is not displaying behavior synonymous with their stated mission. I'd consider that a real problem.


 

No comments: