Okay. You know how I wrote about The Blair Witch Project (1999) being an "early bringer" of the Found Footage genre? Well, so is The St. Francisville Experiment. It was released a year later, but not to theatres and hype and a scintillating website like Blair Witch. It went straight to VHS/DVD, which explains its relative obscurity.
The St. Francisville Experiment opens with a producer outlining the experiment: four non-professionals are going to spend 24 hours in a haunted house, exploring it top-to-bottom and filming the entire time. But it's not just any haunted house. It's none other than the New Orleans plantation home of Delphine LaLaurie. LaLaurie was a socialite in the 1800s who was discovered to be a brutal, sadistic serial killer. She practiced her bloody dark arts on her unfortunate slaves. One of the enslaved women, who was chained to the stove, started a fire, which led to the staggering discovery. Living and dead bodies, including children, were found in the attic. LaLaurie and her family fled in the night. It's said that she later died in Paris.
I really wanted The St. Francisville Experiment to work. I was rooting for it the whole time. The house was sufficiently creepy. The camerawork was good--remember, the movie-making landscape did not have precedent for found footage in the year 2000, and in my opinion the camerawork here is far superior to Blair Witch. So too are the characters superior. Not that we have to compare The St. Francisville Experiment to The Blair Witch Project, it's just the fact of their close proximity in release date, plus the found footage thing. In The St. Francisville Experiment, the purpose of the experiment is noble--you get the sense that four participants really want to help these trapped earthbound spirits to move on. All four are natural and credible, most of all likeable. I especially appreciate The Psychic, portrayed by Madison Charap.
Madison Charap |
She hasn't acted in much in the last 25 years, which is too bad, because she is so compelling. Madison's participation in the foursome is to perform blessings (lots of "bathing in white light" talk), lead a seance using a Ouija board, keep everyone else calm, and to sense and communicate with spirits in the house. When I looked Madison up (because of course I did) I found that she really is a psychic (because of course she is). Outstanding.
Spoilers ahead!
So what didn't work? Well that's just it--it mostly did, right up until the end. It ended with Madison screaming, a blurry camera shot, one of the guys in the doorway looking at something scary, which we can't see, and then the closing shot is a short blurb (text) telling us the fate of the four ghost hunters. And they're fine.
What? That's it?
As far as found footage goes, I'd have to call The St. Francisville Experiment a success, for all the reasons I mentioned before--creepy house, good camera work, good characters and acting. But as for story, this one had so much promise! And so much set-up! Only to end too soon! It feels like they just kind of ran out of...time? Budget? Or they just didn't quite know how to end things. There's a long scene in which Paul is about to go into the attic for a second time but he's too scared to open the door and enter. He feels cold. The others are encouraging him, especially Madison. I mean it's a really long scene, but it works to build suspense. The problem is it just doesn't deliver. I guess he enters the attic? It's not clear. Honestly that final text screen feels like a cop-out, and an insult to the viewers. All four ghost hunters are fine? What about Paul and the haunted attic? What about the ghost(s)? Did Madison's blessings help them move on? Why was Madison screaming at the end, when she seemed so in control the whole time? What or whom did she see?
The St. Francisville Experiment is almost a really good found footage movie. In my opinion, it's ruined by all these unanswered questions and a cop-out of an ending. Even so, I'd recommend it, if only just for the magic that is Madison Charap.👻